The best thing to be said about Suisei no Gargantia is that PIG's animation is top-notch, even if they tent to flaunt hair motion. Visuals are absolutely fabulous.

Other than the visuals, however, content is fairly light... Not light as in "fluff", but light as in "diet". The scope of the story is larger than just the love story, but explanations are not very tight. Most obvious examples are inexplicable abilities of the magical mecha and the absurd geophysics and meteorology of the mystic Earth. The enjoyment very much depends on how much one can suspend the reason and gorge on the pretty pictures. SDB could not, while Brick succeeded. FWIW, Evirus was mildly positive. I wish I could spoil a moment in the finale which made me think that Urobutcher was going to strike after all (compare it with essentially same scene in RahXephon's finale), but... Oh, what the heck, everyone knows that he didn't.

Liked: Yes
Rewatch: This is no Shingu